Wednesday, February 22, 2012

"Ban on Fast Food TV Advertising"

Here's the link to the article for Friday: "Ban on Fast Food TV Advertising"
And if you can't access the link, here's the full text of the article:

Ban On Fast Food TV Advertising Would Reverse Childhood Obesity Trends, Study Shows

ScienceDaily (Nov. 19, 2008) — A ban on fast food advertisements in the United States could reduce the number of overweight children by as much as 18 percent, according to a new study being published this month in the Journal of Law and Economics. The study also reports that eliminating the tax deductibility associated with television advertising would result in a reduction of childhood obesity, though in smaller numbers.

The study was conducted by researchers from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) with funding from the National Institutes of Health. NBER economists Shin-Yi Chou of Lehigh University, Inas Rashad of Georgia State University, and Michael Grossman of City University of New York Graduate Center co-authored the paper, which measures the number of hours of fast food television advertising messages viewed by children on a weekly basis.

The authors found that a ban on fast food television advertisements during children's programming would reduce the number of overweight children ages 3-11 by 18 percent, while also lowering the number of overweight adolescents ages 12-18 by 14 percent. The effect is more pronounced for males than females.

Though a ban would be effective, the authors also question whether such a high degree of government involvement—and the costs of implementing such policies—is a practical option. Should the U.S. pursue that path, they would follow Sweden, Norway and Finland as the only countries to have banned commercial sponsorship of children's programs.

"We have known for some time that childhood obesity has gripped our culture, but little empirical research has been done that identifies television advertising as a possible cause," says Chou, the Frank L. Magee Distinguished Professor at Lehigh's College of Business and Economics. "Hopefully, this line of research can lead to a serious discussion about the type of policies that can curb America's obesity epidemic."

The study also found that the elimination of tax deductibility tied to advertising would similarly produce declines in childhood obesity, albeit at a smaller rate of 5-7 percent. Advertising is considered a business expense and, as such, it can be used to reduce a company's taxable income. The authors deduce that, since the corporate income tax rate is 35 percent, the elimination of the tax deductibility of food advertising costs would be equivalent to increasing the price of advertising by 54 percent.

Such an action would consequently result in the reduction of fast food advertising messages by 40 percent for children, and 33 percent for adolescents.

The study—the largest of its kind to directly tie childhood obesity to fast food advertising on American television—is based on the viewing habits of nearly 13,000 children using data from the 1979 Child-Young Adult National Longitudinal Survey of Youth and the 1997 National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, both issued by the U.S. Department of Labor.

A 2006 report issued by the Institute of Medicine indicated there is compelling evidence linking food advertising on television and increased childhood obesity. "Some members of the committee that wrote the report recommended congressional regulation of television food advertisements aimed at children, but the report also said that the final link that would definitively prove that children had become fatter by watching food commercials aimed at them cannot be made," says Grossman.

"Our study provides evidence of that link," he says.

The Centers for Disease Control estimate that, between 1970 and 1999, the percentage of overweight children ages 6-11 more than tripled to 13 percent. Adolescents between the ages of 12 and 19 also saw a significant increase, reaching 14 percent.

Research indicates that there is an 80 percent chance an overweight adolescent will be an obese adult and that over 300,000 deaths can be attributed to obesity and weight in the United States every year.

27 comments:

  1. After reading this article I really think something has to be done to stop childhood obesity. There is way too many obese people out there and if they do not do anything about it they will have a lot of health issues. By banning fast food tv commercials on children channels less children will be aware of fast food and not want it. By doing this maybe it could help with childhood obesity. Does anybody else agree that they should ban fast food commercials.

    Marcus Chavez

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Marcus, I can see what your point is on banning fast food commercials. I dont think that they should ban the commercials because of child obesity. I think parents need to take more control and responsibility for what they are feeding their kids.

      David Ramey

      Delete
    2. I think it would be a great idea to ban fast food advertising I think it would really help kids not be aware of what they might be missing out on.

      Amanda M.

      Delete
  2. Marcus I do agree that banning fast food would help decrease the desire to eat fast food, but I do not believe it will stop the epidemic of child obesity here in the United States. The reason I think so is because we have already been subjected to the advertising and we all know how McDonalds, Wendy's, and Burger King taste and so forth. People will always eat there. No matter the amount of health claims and warnings. I say this because people still drink, smoke, tan in tanning beds, do drugs both legal and illegal that have many side effects.. I could go on and on. We all know these things are bad for us, yet we continuously partake. I think that more knowledge about how to keep ourselves healthy by eating the right foods and seeing the effects of what unhealthy foods can do to our bodies. I think that could more effectively change the obesity epidemic. Do you agree?

    Kirstin Halverson

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really think it will help though. Dont you all think that stoping or filtering the amount of commercials that are on tv will help young children? Children see something and then they want it, if you dont show them it could help.
      Brock Richins

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  3. When watching the Dove Onslaught commercial I realized what a huge influence the beauty industry is on women especially. There is also another Dove commercial that talks basically about the same thing except it shows this average girl getting made up and then when they take her picture.. they photoshop her to make her neck longer, eyes bigger, jaw different... And that is who we women try to look like. An unrealistic image of a desirable woman. What do you think about the influence of the beauty industry?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It has a huge impact. You (assuming you do buy make up), or anyone else for that matter, wouldn't buy make up if it didn't have an influence.

      Delete
  4. This article is kind of shady for me because I have no idea how these economists got their results. When I read the article, I looked the whole time for their process of investigation. I never found it. Did anyone else run into this concern also?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can see how the research may not make sense. It does seem a little far fetched.

      Delete
  5. This commercial, Kristin? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=knEIM16NuPg

    I would have to agree with all of you. I believe that something should be done about the commercials and the marketing of fast food restaurants, it attracts kids mainly, because they want the stupid toy that is in the happy meal. But there are lots of things we give in to, that are bad for us, like the commercial for Dove. But the main thing that concerns me is the obesidy epidemic. Because not only can it lead to children overweight, and no physical activity. It also contributes to diabetes, heart disease, high cholesterol, etc. A lot more children are being diagnosed with diabetes as a child/teenager. I went to elementary/jr high with a kid who had to prick his finger every day! I just think it is scary. It isn't JUST the fast food place's fault, sometimes it is our own or our parents. Because it really is a lot easier to go buy something through the drive-thru rather than slave over the stove. YET, I have realized that whenever you cook at home, majority of the time it is cheaper, and healthier (:

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that commercials can also be changed to be a good thing for the kids. The toy can be a great thing to get the kids in to the resturaunt. Then its the resturaunts jobs to put healthier good in the meals. Toys can get kids to eat healthier food, those are just the facts.

      Brock Richins

      Delete
  6. I'm really at an odds with two sides being that it is either 100% the advertising or 100% parenting. It would be better to see that the fast food industry had products that promoted healthier food in general not just healthier choices from the menu. The whole menu should be nutrionally adequate along the lines of lesser sodium, fat, and preservative content. The thing to remember and consider is that due to the economy and the agricultural industry isn't exactly top not in producing enough the prices are just too much for any of the larger fast food chains to invest in all natural products rather than that scary pink goo filler they put in mcdonald's chicken nuggets. On the parenting aspect, if you've given your kids something tasty before they'll want it again especially if there's a little something extra called a toy in the kids meal. Banning the advertising of toys still hasn't stopped the children to demand their parents that they want it. They already know that it's guaranteed to get a tiny toy. If we did ban fast food advertising do you honestly think that the newer generations will just forget completely? That's where I don't entirely believe that the ban will work. The fast food industry hires the advertising companies to create a successful pitch. Given the right factors and material, advertising conveys a silver lining to any death inducing product. The fallacy here is almost like the Red Herring idea that they are ignoring the real underlying issue. Food can still be fast but with healthier ingredients all together.

    Rebecca B.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Rebecca makes a lot of very good points with whose fault it really is in childhood obesiity. If we blame the industry then we need to do something about it and have them produce healthier food. On the other hand if we blame parents then they need to not introduce the terrible food to children in the first place.

    Marcus C.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think the real problem is on the parents. Lets be honest children can not drive themselves to Wendy's and Arby's. Majority of the blame is on the parents in this issue. What do you all think?

    Brock Richins

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i believe it is up to the parents to but only for so long. Once kids are in junior high or high school it makes it a little easier for them to get to fast food places for lunch or with friends.

      Amanda M.

      Delete
    2. I agree with both of you on this one. Although I do think that parents only have control for so long. Once they do start driving and have a job making their own money the parents lose some of their control. But do you think that if the parents promoted a healthy life style for their kids from the begining, do you think they would have the desire to ever eat out?
      -Ashley Bench

      Delete
  9. It's been a while since I've read that one too! I wish I was smart enough to have stayed on top of these! I think that fast food restaurants should advertise to their hearts content because they need to make money and the advertisements are obviously aimed at the people who don't have enough self control to choose something healthy to eat. And if you don't have enough self control to not go to McDonalds everyday, then you probably deserve to be overweight.

    ReplyDelete
  10. In all reality i think that if fast food and restaurants picked fresh and healthier foods then the world will be better off!

    Jackie M.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Healthy food is hard to get fast, and that is the number one reason why people don't eat healthier.

    Jackie M.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you Jackie because healthy food does take a while to make but in the long run will help you live a better life.

      Christian Farr

      Delete
  12. Its not that healthy food is hard to get fast, its that people are getting really lazy. If people would stop watching TV all the time they would be able to make cheap healthy lunches for the next day. Eliminating the need for fast food.

    Tilar L

    ReplyDelete
  13. Does anyone find it hard to keep the kids in your life (kids, neices, nephews, cousins)from wanting fast food places mainly because they want the toy in the meal or to even go play on the toys in the restaurant?

    Amanda M.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Do you guys think it is the parents to blame for their children's obesity, or the companies and it's advertisements? I think kids just really want the toy in the happy meal so they beg their parents to go get them fast food.

    Christian Farr

    ReplyDelete
  15. To answer your question Christian, I think the blame goes both ways. Yes fast food chains direct their advertisement more towards kids then they do adults, but I think the final decision falls on the parents and what they allow their kids to eat regularly.
    -Ashley Bench

    ReplyDelete
  16. Lets play a scenario for all of the people who haven't been around very many babies, toddlers, middle schoolers etc. By reading this, how has this influenced to raise your future children to know and what not to know? Fill in the blank, When I have kids they will learn to know that ____________. I will set an example/discipline my children with knowledge of ________. (this goes for eating habits and what you fill your cupboards with) Also, will TV be your babysitter? think about that as relation to blaming the advertising companies.

    Rebecca B.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I just remembered a photo shopped image my daughter showed me that was titled "Fast Food Hits Africa". It's awesome, I just made myself a note to email it to you. It is of an extremely overweight giraff.

    Brad C.

    ReplyDelete